This is a commentary on Gned's recent compilation "Seventeen Songs About A Girl" - which can be found
here.
Some of these songs I know, some I don't - but it looks promising, so we'll go through them all and then see what we think. I should note that Gned's album cover is super-duper-great (and there's a cat on it!) - this puts me to considerable shame. Let's begin.
1. Pixies - "Cecilia Ann" from "Bossanova" (1990)
A quick start to the album with some classic Pixies surf rock. Energetic and propulsive - Bossanova is a great album! OK. This isn't Bossanova - but Gned has selected two songs from that album (and additional songs Alison and Ana could have been used): Gned has chosen well.
2. Elf Power - "Jane" from "A Dream In Sound" (1999)
I like this one. Did you know that Jane is my mum's name? This is impossibly sweet and lovely - a charming song - I should listen to more Elf Power. So far, so good!
3. Damien Rice - "Amie" from "O" (2003)
A little slower and "singer/songwritery" - this will take a couple of listens to figure out. "The Story of O" is a famous 50-year old French erotic novel (published anonymously). This is reminiscent of David Gray or Ed Harcourt. Surprisingly - I like this: hopeful yet bittersweet - perfect for this sort of compilation.
4. Elliott Smith - "Pisteleh" from "XO" (1998)
Ironically, this is the first of two songs(!) that Gned has taken from the same album that I used on my previous compilation ("Mary Jo" is the other). This is classic Elliott Smith: fragile, beautiful - and if you look at the lyrics quite depressing.
5. The Pogues - "Lorelei" from "Peace and Love" (1989)
Most people think The Pogues are Irish when they are from London - but that's a minor point - why did I bother to mention that? Anyways - this isn't Shane MacGowan singing - but that other guy. This is an underrated song. Yes I like this one. Did you know that the "Lorelei" he's singing about is a Rhine Maiden who lures sailors to their deaths?
6. Scissor Sisters - "Mary" from "Scissor Sisters" (2004)
We used to have a Siamese Cat named Mary. Meow! Anyways - I don't like this very much... but we'll give it a chance. Let's come back to this. No - still don't like it. Do other people like this? It seems phoney. It's fake camp retro - I just don't get it.
7. Weezer - "Suzanne" from "Mallrats Soundtrack" (1995)
A straight-ahead stomp from Weezer. I do like Weezer but this song is relatively generic.
8. Björk - "Isobel" from "Post" (1996)
An excellent song! I remember an interview with Björk in AP where she discussed what this song is about - and I recall it had forest creatures transforming into points of light and other bizarre things. A great jungly atmospheric vibe here. The best song on her otherwise disappointing followup to "Debut".
9. Pinback - "Penelope" from "Blue Screen Life" (2001)
MuppetGirl famously got us all interested in Pinback by including 3 different Pinback songs on her last compilation. At the time, they were some of my least favourite songs on her album - but now they are amongst my favourites. I don't know why my tastes changed like that - probably because Pinback are not simple musically so they stand up well to repeated listenings. But this is now my favourite Pinback song - wonderful. You know - I think he's singing about a fish? Does everyone else love Pinback?
10. Jack Johnson - "Taylor" from "On And On" (2003)
Ouch! A real stinker. This is terrible. I hate the way that Jack sings here. The music annoys me. OK Gned - I'll give this a chance - but only for you. Taylor was my grandmother's maiden name - it's not a first name! Hmmm.. Oh - please make this stop. He just said "finger-lickin". I don't like this at all. Gned - why did you include this? Please re-evaluate your tastes.
11. Yo La Tengo - "Andalucia" from "Fakebook" (1990)
This is a John Cale cover, and it's pretty good. There's a double meaning here in that Andalusia is a region of Spain: the last reconquered from the Moors in 1492. I don't know - this is slow and smooth like most Yo La Tengo. I like this better the second time through - nice to sit very deep into the couch to listen to this.
12. Franz Ferdinand - "Jacqueline" from "Franz Ferdinand" (2004)
I should like this more than I do. It's OK. The kids like these guys - and I should too. I don't know what's wrong with me.
13. Lamb - "Angelica" from "Between Darkness and Wonder" (2003)
An electronica number - albeit a slow one - a good change of pace. OK - instrumental so far... is there singing? I hope not. A little too "boingy" for me. But it's nice. I uses "nice" all the time in writing this - I had to remove 90% of them and there's still too many.
14. Belle and Sebastian - "Mary Jo" from "Tigermilk" (1996)
The great closer to "Tigermilk" (which references "The State I Am In" in the lyrics). For some reason, this one is underrated amongst the B&S fanbase. I love this character portrait of a woman much like "Margaret" in "Searching for Boris". OK - I admit that I love B&S and am not giving objective commentary here. Interestingly - the background vocals are sung by a girl named "Isobel" - is that a coincidence? Probably. Note at the end that he says "The men you left for dead" not "dad".
15. Pixies - "Velouria" from "Bossanova" (1990)
One of the best Pixies songs ever! The lyrics are typically nonsensical, of course. If you don't already own "Bossanova", "Doolittle", and "Trompe Le Monde", then get thee to a record store. I do wish that Black Francis had let Kim Deal sing more.
16. Smashing Pumpkins - "Luna" from "Siamese Dream" (1993)
The closer from the much-maligned Smashing Pumpkins. People have forgotten that this is a great album - and I really like this song. Well resurrected! "I'm in love with you" - a sweet message. Inspired choice, Gned!
17. Sinead O'Connor - "Peggy Gordon" (traditional) from "Sean-Nós Nua" (2002)
Like most people, I am unfamiliar with Sinead's later works. This is my fault. Anyways - it is interesting that she was so huge and mainstream (circa 1990) and now no one knows even if she's alive. This is excellent. It sounds like we're in Ireland and I'm shedding a tear as I can smell the streets of Roscommon. O Ireland, I will return to you soon. A great closer to a fine CD.
OK - so those were the songs.
But a compilation is not about the individual songs - it's about the flow and the mood. Has Gned succeeded? Yes. Yes he has. This is good actually. There was only one song I really hated, a couple of poor songs, with the rest being great. A wonderful compilation from Gned.
Note: You can comment directly on Gned's compilation
here. Let's stop using my Ray entry for Gned comments. Cheers!